Paul Verhoeven’s "Benedetta"
Movie review by Dennis D. McDonald
Let me be clear: I don’t buy a supernatural explanation for stigmata, wounds visited on the faithful that resemble those Jesus suffered during his crucifixion. But over the centuries, people have taken claims of stigmata seriously, especially when medicine had little scientific grounding and religion ruled the lives of so many.
Benedetta tells the story of one such case. In a 17th-century convent, a young nun has visions and develops painful, bloody stigmata. Those who take her seriously overrule the doubters. They realize that her story could bring the church both publicity and revenue.
It’s a Verhoeven film, so expect nudity and scenes that will shock and repulse many people. But the film is meticulously produced and photographed, the acting is excellent throughout, and the film does raise significant questions about faith, power, and religious politics.
Many will find this film offensive. Given Verhoeven’s reputation, I’m surprised he got the money to make it. But there’s no question it’s well produced and bound to rattle many cages. You have been warned.
Review copyright © 2026 by Dennis D. McDonald
