All in Music

Ashutosh Gowariker's “LAGAAN: ONE UPON A TIME IN INDIA”

This 3-hour-plus historical-drama-cum-sports-extravaganza has something for everybody: * Little guy against big guy * Noble farmers vs. evil foreign conquerors * The Big Game at the end where everything is decided * Girl From The Country competes with Girl From The City for the same dashing hero * Pleas for religious and social tolerance * An intermission (!)

Joel Schumacher's “THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA”

I’ve never been a fan of this musical. The songs are repetitive and dull, the story is silly, and the overriding themes remind me of the covers of those paperback romance novels you see on sale in supermarkets. But I loved the movie, even though the three points I made above are painfully obvious. So why did I like it?